← All 12 chapters

Chapter 06

The first browser war

Netscape and Microsoft were not only fighting to build the best program. They fought over the rules of the Web, the default place on the desktop and, ultimately, over who controlled the internet’s front door.

Netscape versus Microsoft · 1995–2001

A browser becomes a position of power

In 1995 Netscape looked unassailable. Navigator was fast, recognisable and, for many users, simply was the Web. Microsoft started far behind, but released new versions of Internet Explorer at high speed and tied the browser ever more closely to Windows. Within a few years, the balance had reversed.

The contest became known as the browser war, yet that phrase hides how much was at stake. Whoever controlled the browser influenced which home page people saw, which technologies web builders used and which services opened by default. A button, a setting or a proprietary fragment of HTML could steer millions of users.

1995 The challenger arrives

Internet Explorer enters a market dominated by Netscape.

1997 Version 4 versus version 4

IE4 and Communicator 4 turn features and distribution into an arms race.

1998 Windows 98 and Mozilla

Microsoft integrates IE further; Netscape opens Communicator’s source code.

1999 The roles have reversed

IE has passed Navigator. A US judge finds that Microsoft abused monopoly power.

2001 IE6 closes the era

Microsoft dominates the desktop; the parties reach a proposed settlement.

Every new feature became a lure

Netscape had set the pace in the early years with cookies, JavaScript, frames and plug-ins. Microsoft responded with proprietary extensions such as ActiveX and the moving <marquee> element. Netscape, in turn, had <blink> and later its own layers system for dynamic pages.

Some innovations were eventually adopted widely; others disappeared. The problem was that browser makers shipped features before a standard had been agreed. A spectacular page might work in one browser and distort, freeze or remain completely empty in another.

NETSCAPE <blink> and Layers

Attention-grabbing text and positioning through technologies aimed primarily at Navigator.

MICROSOFT <marquee> and ActiveX

Moving text and Windows components that made IE sites more powerful — and platform-dependent.

EVERYONE JavaScript, JScript and DOM

The same ambition, but different object models and code paths for each browser.

A standard existed, but support diverged

The World Wide Web Consortium published CSS1 in December 1996 to separate a page’s presentation from its content. Internet Explorer 3 already supported part of it; Netscape announced support. In practice, implementations were incomplete and inconsistent. Web builders quickly learned which browser bugs they had to work around.

Dynamic HTML in Navigator 4, Internet Explorer 4 and later IE5 made matters still more complicated. The W3C history gives a stark summary: around 1998 professional developers needed to know several ways of writing comparable JavaScript interaction. The Web Standards Project emerged that same year in opposition to this fragmentation.

Netscape sold software; Microsoft gave the browser away

Navigator was often free to try for individuals and available without charge to educational and non-profit users, but Netscape also earned money from licences and business products. Microsoft could offer Internet Explorer at no separate price because Windows and Office generated its income. What looked like free convenience to users undermined Netscape’s business model.

The Navigator box makes that transition tangible. A browser could still be a product you bought, unpacked and consciously installed. During the browser war it increasingly became an invisible part of the computer already sitting on your desk.

A boxed copy of Netscape Navigator in a Computer History Museum display
A retail box of Netscape Navigator in the Computer History Museum collection. The display notes that most people downloaded Navigator, but early versions were available for retail purchase too. Photo: Marcin Wichary, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.

Internet Explorer moves into the desktop

Internet Explorer 4 in 1997 brought the browser and Windows Explorer closer together, visually and technically. With the optional Windows Desktop Update, folders could behave like web pages and Active Desktop could display web content on the desktop. Windows 98 went further: IE was present, prominent and, Microsoft argued, part of the operating system.

This integration gave Microsoft more than a shortcut. PC manufacturers and users could not easily treat IE like an ordinary program. Findings in the US Microsoft case described how licence terms, default settings and technical connections made it harder to remove the browser or give Netscape equal visibility.

WINDOWS operating system → IE visible by default → WEB one click away

Dutch perspective · best viewed with…

The browser war appeared at the bottom of the home page

Dutch web builders also had to pick a side. Personal home pages, club sites and small business pages carried badges reading ‘Best viewed with Netscape Navigator’ or ‘Best viewed with Internet Explorer’. An ideal display resolution often appeared beside them: 800 × 600 pixels, or even 640 × 480.

N

BEST VIEWED WITH
NETSCAPE

e

BEST VIEWED WITH
EXPLORER

800 × 600
HIGH COLOR RECOMMENDED

Such a badge was more than decoration. It revealed that the builder had mainly tested the page in one environment — and passed the problem to the visitor: install another browser if this site does not work. The National Library of the Netherlands preserves more than 3,000 XS4ALL home pages from 1993–2001. These personal pages show particularly clearly how browser choice, HTML experimentation and Dutch internet culture overlapped.

The badges above are new CSS reconstructions inspired by 1990s visual language; they are not copied from the KB collection.

Explore the KB collection of XS4ALL home pages →

The contest moves into the courtroom

In May 1998 the US Department of Justice and twenty states sued Microsoft. The central issue was not that Internet Explorer was good, free or popular, but that Microsoft used its power in PC operating systems to restrict competition in browsers.

1998 The complaint

The government says Microsoft uses Windows to favour Internet Explorer.

1999–2000 Finding and judgment

The court finds monopoly abuse; an order to split the company follows.

2001–2002 Appeal and settlement

The break-up is reversed. Microsoft accepts conduct rules and oversight.

The case partly revolved around the details that looked so harmless at home: which icon was visible, which browser opened by default and how much freedom a computer manufacturer possessed. Microsoft won the browser market, but the methods it used acquired a legal boundary.

Defeat contained the beginning of a return

In January 1998 Netscape decided to release the source code of the next Communicator version. On 31 March code became available through mozilla.org. It did not produce a fast successor immediately: the old code was difficult to modernise and the new Gecko engine took years of work. Even so, this became Netscape’s most important legacy.

AOL acquired Netscape in 1999. Navigator continued to lose ground while Internet Explorer dominated the desktop around the turn of the century. Mozilla, however, survived as an open project. Firefox would eventually emerge from that long detour — the subject of chapter 9.

NETSCAPE CODE 31 March 1998 MOZILLA

A commercial defeat becomes the start of an open counterforce.

The winner also set the pace

With IE6 in Windows XP, the war seemed over in 2001. For many sites Internet Explorer became the only environment that truly mattered. This made the Web simpler for builders in the short term, but more dependent on one supplier. Innovation slowed, and proprietary IE technology remained embedded in companies and public organisations for many years.

The first browser war proved two things that would return later: a browser is never merely a window, and a standard only has value when competing browsers implement it in the same way.

Sources